Claims Guide — Cover My Order Documentation
Documentation / Claims

Claims Guide

How claims work in Cover My Order — from a customer's report to your reserve ledger.

Free & Premium ~7 min read
1

Before a Claim Happens: What Your Customer Sees

If a customer opted into shipping protection at checkout, they'll see a "File a claim" option in three places:

  • Their My Account → Orders page, next to any protected order.
  • A claims block or shortcode, if you've added one to a dedicated page.
  • A link in the shipping confirmation or delivery-issue email, if you've customized your transactional emails to include one.

They don't need an account beyond their normal WooCommerce customer account — no separate login, no third-party portal.

2

Filing a Claim

When a customer starts a claim, they're asked to:

  1. Select the order the claim relates to (pre-filled if they came from the Orders page).
  2. Choose a reason — Lost in transit, Damaged on arrival, or Stolen/missing after delivery.
  3. Add notes describing what happened.
  4. Upload evidence — up to 10 photo files, 10MB each by default (filterable via a code hook if you need different limits).
  5. Submit.

The claim is immediately created with status Pending Review and appears in your wp-admin claims queue. The customer receives an automatic email confirmation with their claim reference.

i

Tip: Encourage photo evidence for damaged-item claims specifically — it's the single biggest factor in resolving a claim quickly without back-and-forth.

3

Reviewing a Claim in wp-admin

Go to CoverMyOrder → Claims to see your queue. Each claim shows:

  • Order number and customer
  • Claim reason and submission date
  • Evidence thumbnails (click to view full size)
  • Order's protection plan and coverage cap
  • A risk sidebar — a basic customer risk profile on Free (claim frequency, account age); expanded fraud/geography scoring on Premium (Section 6)

Click into a claim to see the full evidence set, customer notes, and the linked order's shipping/tracking details side by side.

4

Carrier Tracking

If tracking is available on the order:

  • Manual entry — Free and Premium: you (or your fulfillment process) enter tracking manually, and the claim view shows current carrier status alongside the customer's report.
  • AfterShip inbound webhook — Free and Premium: if you use AfterShip, tracking-status updates (e.g., "Delivered," "Exception") flow into the claim automatically as they change.
  • Auto-filed claims (Premium) — when tracking status shows Lost or Damaged, Premium can automatically open a claim with no customer action required, pre-populated with the carrier's own status as evidence.
5

Resolving a Claim

Once you've reviewed the evidence, you have two resolution paths:

Free & Premium

Refund

Issues a refund through your existing payment gateway for the claimed amount (up to the plan's coverage cap), and logs a payout entry in the reserve ledger.

Premium only

Reship

Marks the claim resolved via replacement shipment instead of a refund — useful when the customer wants the item, not their money back. Doesn't touch the reserve ledger the same way a refund does, since no payout occurs.

Click Approve, choose the resolution type, and confirm. The claim status updates to Resolved, the customer is notified automatically, and — for refunds — the reserve ledger gets a new payout line immediately (Section 7).

You can also Deny a claim, with a required internal note explaining why (this note is not shown to the customer by default, but your denial message is — customize it under CoverMyOrder → Settings → Claim Messages).

6

Automation Rules PREMIUM

Instead of reviewing every claim manually, Premium lets you set rules under CoverMyOrder → Automation:

  • Threshold-based auto-approval — claims under a value you set (e.g., under $50) can auto-approve without an operator, as long as they don't trip a fraud flag.
  • Fraud and abuse flags — risk scoring based on geography and seasonal signals, plus the customer's own claim history, holds suspicious claims for manual review even if they're under your auto-approval threshold.
  • Per-customer payout caps — limits how much any single customer account can claim within a period, regardless of how many separate claims they file.
  • Carrier recovery — when a claim involving a lost/damaged shipment is approved, Premium can automatically open a recovery record with FedEx/UPS/USPS on your behalf, so you have a shot at recovering cost from the carrier even after paying out the customer.
i

Tip: Start conservative — a low auto-approval threshold (e.g., $25–35) catches most low-friction claims automatically while keeping anything meaningful in front of a human.

7

How Claims Affect Your Reserve Ledger

Every approved refund writes an entry to CoverMyOrder → Reserve Ledger:

  • The original premium collected at checkout was already logged as an incoming entry.
  • The claim payout is logged as an outgoing entry, linked back to the same order.
  • Your running reserve balance updates immediately — this is the figure that tells you, at a glance, whether premiums collected are keeping pace with payouts.
  • Entries are immutable — appended, never edited or overwritten, so the ledger stays defensible to an accountant.

CSV export of the full ledger (claims, protections, and reserve) is a Premium feature, for reconciliation outside wp-admin.

8

Claim Statuses Reference

StatusMeaning
Pending ReviewNewly submitted, awaiting your action
Under ReviewYou've opened it but haven't resolved it yet (optional manual flag)
Auto-ApprovedResolved automatically by an Automation Rule (Premium)
Resolved — RefundedApproved and refund issued
Resolved — ReshippedApproved and replacement sent (Premium)
DeniedReviewed and declined, with an internal note
9

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a customer file more than one claim per order?

Yes, if the order contains multiple shipments or partial issues — each is tracked as a separate claim linked to the same order.

What happens if I don't respond to a claim?

There's no automatic timeout or forced resolution — claims sit in Pending Review until you act, though we recommend setting an internal SLA (many merchants aim for 24–48 hours) since unresolved claims are a common source of "where is my refund" support tickets.

Can I edit the claim reasons customers choose from?

Yes, under CoverMyOrder → Settings → Claim Reasons — add, remove, or relabel reasons to match how you want to categorize issues internally.

Does resolving a claim notify the customer automatically?

Yes — approval, denial, and reship all trigger an automatic email using the templates under CoverMyOrder → Settings → Claim Messages, which you can customize.